Movie Review

The Narrow Margin

The Narrow Margin Movie Poster

US Release Date: 05-04-1952

Directed by: Richard Fleischer


  • Charles McGraw
  • Det. Sgt. Walter Brown
  • Marie Windsor
  • Mrs. Frankie Neall
  • Jacqueline White
  • Ann Sinclair
  • Gordon Gebert
  • Tommy Sinclair
  • Queenie Leonard
  • Mrs. Troll
  • David Clarke
  • Joseph Kemp
  • Peter Virgo
  • Densel
Average Stars:
Reviewed on: October 17th, 2009
This is one taut thriller.

This is one taut thriller.

This is one taut thriller. It begins in Chicago at night. Two detectives have arrived to escort the widow of a gangster to the D.A. in Los Angeles. The action kicks off within the first few minutes and the tension never lets up. The hit men after the widow don’t know what she looks like. Thus begins a game of cat and mouse that takes place almost entirely on a train. If you’ve never seen it, this is all the information you want.

For those unfamiliar with film noir this picture makes a great introduction. It features all of the classic elements. A man and a woman on a dangerous journey together; mistaken identities and lots of shadows. The Narrow Margin uses sound in a brilliant manner, especially the various noises of the train. The dialogue is stark and dramatic.

Charles McGraw is superb as the tough-as-nails Detective Walter Brown. His gruff speaking voice, stocky build and none to pleasing mug are just what the part called for. He barks out lines like “Shut up!” and “You’re off your stick - way off.” The rest of the cast are equally impressive.

Today’s directors could learn a thing or two by studying the work that Richard Fleischer did here. This movie is only 72 minutes long and there isn’t a wasted shot. The action is realistic and never over-the-top. It has thrills as well as heart and is cleverly shot. To the point that the train becomes another character. I realize I am gushing but I honestly can’t find fault with this picture in any way. Check it out for yourself if you don’t believe me.

Reviewed on: July 8th, 2013
Charles McGraw and Marie Windsor in The Narrow Margin.

Charles McGraw and Marie Windsor in The Narrow Margin.

This tight little thriller was shot in just two week on a budget of roughly $200 thousand. It was one of RKO's most profitable pictures. Howard Hughes, then owner of RKO, enjoyed the film so much that he kept it from being released for 18 months as he pondered whether or not to remake it as an A-picture. It would eventually get remade as such, but not for almost 40 more years with Gene Hackman and Anne Archer in the lead roles. Unlike the original that remake was generally considered a disappointment.

As Patrick wrote, the film takes place almost entirely onboard the train. This creates an often claustrophobic atmosphere that director Richard Fleischer makes good use of. His camera follows his characters up and down the corridors and into state rooms. Accompanying the action is the constant sound of the train, which is the film's only soundtrack as the film is completely devoid of background music. You can see the influence of this film in later movies on a train, such as 1976's Silver Streak. You can also detect its influence on several of the James Bond novels such as Live and Let Die and From Russia with Love.

The acting is generally good with McGraw making a particularly good no-nonsense, tough guy cop. He doesn't so much speak his lines as growl them. Marie Windsor is also excellent as the femme fatale. You can feel the heat between her and McGraw even as she spits and claws at him like a wildcat. Jacqueline White seems downright dull by comparison as the "good girl".

Although the film is highly enjoyable, there are some dubious plot holes. They are impossible to discuss without giving away the ending, which comes with a twist, but suffice to say that with hindsight not all of the action makes sense. There are plenty of opportunities for Sgt. Brown to take a different action than he does, but always fails to do so. These moments don't really take away the fun of the film, but they are there if you want to look.

Not a completely perfect film, but definitely an entertaining one.

Reviewed on: March 18th, 2015
Charles McGraw and Jacqueline White in The Narrow Margin

Charles McGraw and Jacqueline White in The Narrow Margin

Although I was entertained by The Narrow Margin, I kept finding flaws in it. The first and obvious one is why no one locks their doors and why does the detective keep answering his. “No, I do not have your suitcase. I am sleeping. Go away!” Funny how no one knows what the mob boss’s wife looks like but everyone knows the detective from across the country.

This detective is nearly incompetent. After his partner gets killed, he runs after the shooter, leaving the woman he is supposed to be protecting behind. He travels about the train stirring up trouble. He busts into a compartment occupied by a nanny and a young boy, who later recognizes him and announces out loud that he has a gun. Had he stayed in his compartment he would not have upset the fat guy who wants his “extra” room, again bringing attention to himself even though he is trying to lay low.

He is very obvious when he tails the hood throughout the train. His actions cause a blonde woman to be mistaken for the mob wife.  The blonde, who is also the boy’s mother, flirts with the detective and believes he is interested in her as well.  In a very brief amount of time, this undercover cop pisses innocent people off, attracts the attention of a nice looking woman and allows a child to announce to everyone in ear shot that he carries a gun.

Detective Walter Brown may be tough-as-nails but he is dumb as dirt. The twist reveals just how bad he is at his job. At least, as Patrick wrote, he has a way with words. “What do you take me for, a jumbo sized sucker?” They are very fitting words. There are plenty of decent lines to go around. The woman he is protecting says of their shared fate, “This train's heading straight for the cemetery.”

My favorite part of this movie is the direction. As my brothers wrote, the train is as important to the film as any character. The tight limited locations only add to the feeling of danger. During a fight, the detective’s foot kicks directly into the cameras if it were the other guy’s face. The shot of the moving car outside the train window looks like something in Sin City.

The Narrow Margin is a decent enough film but it is too riddled with flaws for me to award it four stars.