Directed by: Peter Weir
Starring:
In many ways, Witness marked the high-point in Ford's career. Photo copyright: Paramount Pictures (1985)
Ford plays a Philadelphia police detective, John Book, investigating the murder of a fellow cop. The only witness is a young Amish boy, Samuel, who identifies the killer as yet another policeman. After being shot by the suspect, Book takes Samuel and his mother, Rachel, back to their rural farm. Too hurt to return to the city, Book ends up staying on the farm to heal.
Although the movie is book ended by a few action scenes, Witness, at it's heart, is a love story. Rachel's husband recently died and a neighboring Amish man, Daniel, has an eye for her. She, though, is fascinating and very much taken by Book. Their love is forbidden as Book is seen by the Amish as someone outside their order. Rachel and Book's feelings for each other are obvious but subtle. Each moves cautiously around the other like someone building a house of cards, afraid that if they make a sudden move it will all fall apart. They stare constantly at each other. Even when they do not speak you can tell they are pining for each other. The symbolism of Rachel removing her bonnet, near the end, speaks far more than any dialogue could.
As wonderful as the romance plays out, it unfortunately provides the movie's biggest plot hole. After Book heals up he calls his partner, who suggests that they go to the FBI or contact a reporter who would publish the story. Either piece of action would have saved the mother and her boy. Book decides instead to do nothing. Well actually, he does do something. He milks a cow, goes to a barn raising and builds a bird house. People are out there trying to find and kill him, Rachel and Samuel and he's acting like a school kid spending the summer on a farm.
Although it makes little sense for him to stick around, the movie's best moments do come from Ford interacting with the Amish people. My favorite such scene is when a tourist wants to take his picture, thinking he is Amish, and Ford says to her, "Listen, lady, you take my picture and I'm going to rip off your brassiere and strangle you with it."
The movie's best moments come when Ford interacts with the Amish. Photo copyright: Paramount Pictures (1985)
With that kind of a cast, it is amazing that Haas, in fact, steals the entire picture. At nine years of age he conveys the most sincere performance. From casually showing Book the farm, to witnessing the murder, it is Haas who truly draws you into this world of clashing cultures. Weir lingers on his actors faces. He lets their expressions control the scenes and not the dialogue. With Haas, and his big dark eyes, he had the perfect child actor for the role.
Photos © Copyright Paramount Pictures (1985)