Zoe Saldana in Colombiana.

There are unconfirmed rumors that Luc Besson's script for Colombiana was adapted from his long anticipated sequel script to his 1994 film, The Professional. The two movies certainly have similarities. Both feature a young girl whose parents are murdered because of drugs, prompting the young girl to seek a life of revenge. Colombiana differs by showing what happens after the little girl grows up. It also differs by being pretty awful and lacking all the emotional resonance that made The Professional  so good.

The story starts 15 years ago when 9 year old Cataleya's parents are killed by a Colombian drug warlord. Cateleya escapes and with the help of some condemning evidence against the warlord, is granted asylum in the United States. Once there she gives the authorities the slip and makes her way to Chicago where she has a mobster uncle. Cut to modern day and Cataleya is now played by Zoe Saldana and has become an assassin for hire. Her real quest though is to track down and murder the man and his henchmen responsible for her parent's death.

If you're going to cast someone to play a hired killer, that person needs to make you believe they could be a killer. I never bought Zoe Saldana as a killer. Hell, the little girl who plays Cataleya at 9 seems more capable of killing someone than she does. For one thing, it looks like a light wind would knock her over. She has to carry a large sniper rifle at one point and I'm amazed she's able to even pick it up. The few times she actually gets into a fight, with much larger men, it's almost laughable. I had a similar problem with Angelina Jolie's Salt, but at least Jolie has the attitude of a killer, Saldana seems more comfortable in the crying scenes than she does in the action ones. Don't get me wrong, she's hot and a good actress, but this is just simple miscasting.

Even the most perfect casting though wouldn't make up for the incredibly lazy and sloppy writing. As an example, the first kill a grown-up Cataleya performs is in a jail. To gain access to the man she wants to kill she climbs up through the ventilation shaft that is conveniently placed throughout the jail with vents big enough for at least two people to climb through. The vents aren't secured and are able to be opened and closed without tools from inside the prison cells. Oh and the shafts lead from the cells to outside the building.  How do they keep anyone inside?

Later the FBI are lead to Cataleya's house by the most extreme coincidence. Until this point they only know that Cataleya was in the jail as a prisoner and have always assumed that the killer was a man. Instead of merely sending someone around to question her, they send an army in to capture or kill her. They have dozens of police in full armor and lots of explosives to blow up her door. It's a scene lifted almost directly from The Professional, but in that movie it at least made sense.

With the implausible action, the miscasting and the poor script, there's not very much to enjoy. I never really even felt all that much empathy with Cataleya. I did at first when she was 9, but much less so as an adult. In fact, the opening action scene and the subsequent chase are the best parts of the entire film.

If this was going to be the sequel to The Professional, I'm glad it was wasted here. I only hope if Besson does ever get around to making that sequel, he puts more effort into the script than he did with this one.

Did you enjoy Scott's review? +27 -70