We waste our money, so you don't have to!

Movie Review

Vertical Limit

"The Mountain Will Decide."
Directed by: Martin Campbellt
Starring:
Chris O'Donnell - Peter Garrett
Robin Tunney - Annie Garrett
Scott Glenn - Montgomery Wick
Bill Paxton - Elliot Vaughn
Izabella Scorupco - Monique Aubertine
Nicholas Lea - Tom McLaren
Alexander Siddig - Kareem Nazir
Robert Taylor - Skip Taylor

Vertical Limit Movie Poster
Shop for Vertical Limit related products at Amazon.com

US Release Date:
December 8th, 2000


 
Scott Eric Patrick Average
 
Scott
This is not a movie for watching, it is a movie for putting down and avoiding. Vertical Limit tells the story of 3 ill-fated mountain climbers attempting to reach the summit of K-2 who end up trapped during an avalanche, and the rescue attempt to save them.

Oh, the agony, the cold, the discomfort, the pain, and the long wait for the inevitable end of it all. Not the climbers, ME waiting for this incredibly awful movie to finish. In fact, if you ever have the choice of being trapped, halfway up a mountain, or of having to watch this movie, then I advise you to don that parka and long underwear.

In this year of only so-so movies, Vertical Limit ranks right ahead of The Adventures of Rocky & Bullwinkle as worst movie of the year. How can put I put it constructively? It stinks!!!!!!!!

Dialogue no one should ever be allowed to write, let alone speak. Special effects that look so bad, they might as well have left the blue screen in place. Lack of any credible tension. Not one character you can care about. By the end I was just hoping they would all die, along with the writers, directors and producers of this amazingly bad film.

Is there anything good I can say about this movie? The performances weren't horrible. Actually, this movie is the perfect example of how little the actors can actually contribute to a movie. No actor in the world could have made this movie enjoyable, unless Elizabeth Hurley performed all the roles in the nude.

I can not stress this enough, stay away from this movie as if they were handing out the Black Plague along with the tickets. If it wasn't against our policy here at Three Movie Buffs to give out zero stars, this movie would not be getting any. Just trust me that the one star it is receiving is more generous than it deserves.

Did you enjoy Scott's review? +2 -0
 
Eric
The original idea for this film might not have been so bad, but the execution is poor. Vertical Limit is the most amateur piece of film making I have seen this year, and I saw Thomas The Train! Everything that Scott pointed out is pretty accurate. The special effects are an embarrassment To me, however, this movie really blew it in the editing.

In 5 minutes of screen time the climbers go from base camp to cave in. The rescue team takes an hour of screen time, and they got a helicopter ride half way up. I guess they should not have stopped to pray, make tea and ask each other dumb melodramatic questions.

I do feel that after Scott so brutally slammed this movie that I should in some way defend it. The original idea for this film was probably not to bad; an action/adventure rescue on K2. Casting Chris O'Donnell and a bunch of recognizable B actors wasn't a bad move. It does have several high altitude cliff hanging scenes.

This movie could have been great. If only the direction, editing, story lines and special effects were not so lousy.

Did you enjoy Eric's review? +0 -0
 
Patrick
As B a movie as it is possible to be. A brilliant, nonstop thrill-ride with breathtaking cinematography, Oscar caliber performances and a script to rival Casablanca. There aren't enough superlatives in the English language to truly do justice to this unprecedented masterpiece. Chris O'Donnell gives one of the most intense characterizations I have ever witnessed, easily surpassing Brando's in On The Waterfront. Bill Paxton was, quite simply, robbed of the supporting actor Academy Award.

JUST KIDDING. Actually Vertical Limit is pretty awful stuff. There are, however, as Eric said, some scenes of real tension with people hanging off the sides of mountains and the cinematography is good. In fact I believe it garnered it's one and only Oscar nomination in this category.

A 'B' movie in every sense of the word. I would rank this one just behind Congo.

Did you enjoy Patrick's review? +1 -0

Photos © Copyright 2000 Columbia Pictures All Rights Reserved